Introduction

Forks occur when one blockchain splits into two for some amount of time because parts of the network splits on which blocks follow at a point on the blockchain. See the diagram below for a more intuitive description.

There are three main types of forks: temporary forks, hard forks, and soft forks. Each are described in more detail in their own section, but here’s an overview:

Temporary forks happen by accident, but are automatically resolved by your wallet finding the better chain. Hard forks are protocol level changes meaning it cannot be resolved without users on the network upgrading their wallet. Soft forks are like a hard fork, but only restrict existing rules and don’t add their own meaning that existing wallets can still get on the right chain, but they can create blocks rejected by the newly updated wallets

Diagram Explanation

diagram showing a chain of blocks on the top labeled original chain with a split and a second chain at the bottom labeled forked chain

May be harder to see on mobile, so the top chain is labeled “original chain” and the bottom is “forked chain”. Each square is labeled “block”


Temporary Forks

Summary

Temporary forks (sometimes called accidental forks) are the most common type of fork. They almost always happen by accident, but are resolved by your wallet automatically. They usually don’t last long

How They Happen

One way they can happen is if two people stake at the same time. The network will split temporarily until one of the chains wins out. If you’ve ever seen a stake appear and quickly disappear, this is likely what happened — the stake was on a fork and never actually existed on the the real chain

How Your Wallet Resolves It

The wallet sees that two chains exist, but it will notice that one of the chains has higher difficulty (more coins staking) and length and switch to that chain if it’s not already on it. One chain will get higher difficulty and length because the network will not be evenly split between the chains. Since every wallet can agree on the difficulty and length of the two chains, every wallet will get on the same chain eventually.

How It Relates to Confirmations

Confirmations are the number of blocks created after a transaction went into a block. When you send a transaction, you may have noticed that some places require a certain number of confirmations or that your wallet waits before calling a transaction confirmed.

The reason for doing this is that you can be more sure that the transaction wasn’t made only on a fork. If it was, your wallet likely would’ve found the main chain by then.

While most regular transactions can be sent and go onto both chains, there is no guarantee. You may for instance be trying to spend coins generated only on that fork.

Hard Forks

Summary

Hard Forks are almost always intentional1. Hard forks are what happen when there are protocol level changes that are irreconcilable with the previous version of the wallet. The old wallets will reject the blocks after a hardfork from the newer version of the wallet because the new wallets are using features not allowed in the older version.

Relation to Mandatory Upgrades

In short, Mandatory versions are Mandatory because they create Hardforks. The approximate date (and the exact block) given to upgrade by is when the hardfork will occur. If you don’t upgrade to a mandatory version, you will get off the main chain from everyone else that has upgraded and your wallet cannot fix this automatically for you.

How to Get Off a Fork If You Don’t Upgrade

If you don’t upgrade before it happens, your wallet will fork and get off the main chain. To get back on the main chain first try upgrading to the latest version of the wallet and starting the wallet back up. If the hardfork was recent or if your wallet has been offline since before the hardfork, your wallet might be able to correct it itself. If it was a while ago or the wallet has not been able to correct itself after running for a while, you may need to either sync from zero or use a snapshot

Soft Forks

Soft forks are like hardforks in the sense that it’s a protocol change, but instead of adding features, they only remove some. This means an older wallet can still get in sync, but if an older wallet tries to make a block using those removed features, it will fork since the new wallets will reject it.

Soft forks are not as common as hardforks in most cryptocurrencies and certainly in Gridcoin

Other Notes

Different from Software Forks

Blockchain forks are a separate concept from Software forks. Software forks are when the code is used and modified from another project. Gridcoin is a software fork of Peercoin which is a software fork of Bitcoin Core, but all are entirely separate and unrelated blockchains that share 0 blocks in common

Footnotes

  1. There have been instances of accidental hardfork in other cryptocurrencies like in 2013 with Bitcoin due to a bug, but things like this are very rare